Seven of the last ten accounts Claude audited had a conversion tracking problem. Real leads counted as secondary, tags that stopped or never fired, map taps steering the budget. Find out what yours is counting, free.
Smart bidding spends toward whatever your primary conversion actions record. If they record taps instead of leads, or nothing at all, every other optimisation builds on the wrong number. That is why Claude reads tracking before it judges a keyword, a budget, or a bid strategy.
How one tracking mistake spreads
1The wrong thing is countedA test action, a page view, or a call tap is set as primary.
2Bidding learns from itSmart bidding finds people who do that thing, cheaply.
3Reports look fineCost per conversion falls. Leads do not.
4Budget follows the illusionGoogle recommends more budget for the “winning” campaign.
What we found in real accounts
The kinds of tracking cases Claude filed across ten real audits, by how many accounts had each one.
Tracking problems in 10 real audits
A primary action that recorded nothing, or a tag that stopped6
Enhanced conversions for leads off5
Primary actions on mixed attribution models5
Lead actions counting every event, not one per click5
Placeholder value of 1 on every conversion3
Soft or test actions set as primary1
Real conversions stuck in secondary actions1
View as table
Item
Accounts
A primary action that recorded nothing, or a tag that stopped
6
Enhanced conversions for leads off
5
Primary actions on mixed attribution models
5
Lead actions counting every event, not one per click
5
Placeholder value of 1 on every conversion
3
Soft or test actions set as primary
1
Real conversions stuck in secondary actions
1
Accounts with at least one case of each kind. One account can have several.
What Claude checks in your tracking
Every conversion action in the account, plus the places where tracking breaks outside it.
Conversion tracking
Reads: Every conversion action: primary or secondary, counting, value, attribution model, windows, last recorded date.
Real conversions landing in secondary actions while bidding steers on others
Tags that stopped recording, or never recorded at all
Soft actions (page views, taps, directions) and test actions set as primary
Every-count on lead actions, placeholder values of 1, mixed attribution models, enhanced conversions off
Bid strategies
Reads: Each campaign’s strategy, targets, and conversion volume.
Smart bidding running below the conversion volume it needs to learn
Targets out of reach of what the campaign actually costs
Return-based bidding on conversions that carry no real value
Recent changes
Reads: The account change history, matched against day-by-day results.
What changed right before performance moved, and whether the change is to blame
Auto-applied recommendations that removed or changed things
Pauses and edits made outside Boxoo
Tracking case studies
Real accounts, anonymised. Open each to see every case Claude filed.
Home physiotherapy providerUnited Kingdom · GBP
21 of 22 conversions in 30 days were landing in secondary actions, so bidding was steering on a single conversion.
Search only, two live campaigns, a daily budget around £22.
conversions bidding could not see
21 of 22
on one broad keyword, 0 conversions
£52.11
keywords blocked by their own negatives
7
What Claude found (6 cases)
Conversion trackingThe actions that record are not the ones steering bidding
The 8 primary actions recorded 1 conversion between them. The bookings that really came in were all counted as secondary.
Recent changesEvery conversion action stopped at the same moment
22 events in the 11 days to 21 October, then 0 in the next 11 days on 36 clicks. Claude flagged it as a tracking break, not a slow week.
KeywordsA broad keyword spent more than a conversion costs and got nothing back
£52.11 and 0 conversions on broad match, while the phrase copy of the same keyword won 2 conversions for £18.72.
KeywordsSeven exact keywords were also added word for word as negatives
Each one was bid on and blocked at campaign and ad group level, so it could never show.
Ads and assetsThe ads promised same-day visits, a callout still said same-week
Two promises side by side in the same ad, one of them out of date.
Growth opportunitiesMondays converted for a fraction of the cost
Monday brought 4 of the 8 conversions on under a tenth of spend: £7.48 per conversion against £38.24 across the week.
What happened next: The owner applied seven of the fixes from the board right after the audit, including pausing the broad keyword.
Local business with a store and lead formsIndia · INR
All 732 conversions in 30 days were map directions or call-button taps. The lead form and WhatsApp had recorded none.
One Performance Max campaign doing almost all the work, one small Search campaign.
conversions, all directions or call taps
732
actions set as primary, a test one included
12 of 12
conversions behind the campaign the spend limit stopped
596
What Claude found (5 cases)
Google’s recommendationsThe main campaign was bidding toward taps, not leads
Every conversion was a directions request or a call tap. Lead form, WhatsApp, and contact page recorded nothing.
Conversion trackingSoft engagement actions and a test action were all primary
All 12 actions fed bidding, including one named as a test and an engagement action that recorded 2,301 in a month.
Budgets and reachThe account spending limit was used up
Spend had reached the account limit to the rupee, so the campaign behind all 596 conversions was suspended.
Performance MaxEvery conversion was worth exactly 1
A placeholder value, so any return-based target would be meaningless.
Growth opportunitiesSunday to Wednesday converted cheaper, yet the late week took most spend
INR 36.01 per conversion early in the week against INR 47.47 Thursday to Saturday, which took 61% of spend.
Equipment repair businessSaudi Arabia · SAR
No conversion action had ever recorded anything, and the landing page HTML had no Google tag.
One new Search campaign, under SAR 100 in its first week.
conversions recorded by 3 primary actions
0
spent in the first week with nothing measured
SAR 77
ad, so nothing to test it against
1
What Claude found (4 cases)
Conversion trackingThe site may not have a tag at all
All three primary actions recorded 0 in 30 days, and the page’s HTML showed no Google tag.
Recent changesThe only campaign was paused and stayed off
Nothing served for four days after a pause made in Google Ads.
Ads and assetsOne ad, rated Average, carried every click
With no second ad there was no way to tell whether the copy was the problem.
Ads and assetsHalf the callouts Google recommends
Three callouts, each repeating a sitelink, and no structured snippet.
Local emergency serviceSaudi Arabia · SAR
Phone calls were the goal, but the call asset had call reporting off and the tag had not recorded once in 12 months.
One Search campaign in Arabic, SAR 58–84 a month.
without a single recorded conversion
12 months
phone impressions in the month
0
misspelled headlines, one in the city name
2
What Claude found (3 cases)
Conversion trackingNothing had ever been recorded
The contact tag recorded nothing in 12 months while the campaign took clicks.
Conversion trackingCalls were a goal but could not count
The call goal was left out of the Conversions column, and call reporting was off on the newer call asset.
Ads and assetsTwo headlines were misspelled
One of the errors was in the name of the city the ads target.
Small online advertiserUnited Kingdom · GBP
One day recorded 70 conversions on £2.06 of spend, about 30% of the month, and made the account look cheaper than it was.
A small account spending about £10 a day.
conversions on £2.06 in one day
70
per conversion: Tuesday vs the week
£0.20 vs £0.44
What Claude found (3 cases)
Budgets and reachOne day distorted the month
A single day carried about 30% of the 30-day conversions, so cost per conversion read lower than reality.
Budgets and reachThe cheapest campaign was capped by its budget
It spent its full daily ceiling at £0.29 per conversion against an account bar of £0.41.
Growth opportunitiesEarly-week days converted at half the cost
A Tuesday conversion cost £0.20 against £0.44 across the account.
From real Boxoo audits, read in November 2026. We removed names, brands, cities, and identifying search terms; the numbers are exactly what Claude reported, in each account’s own currency.
What is your account counting? The audit reads every conversion action and tells you which ones bidding really uses.
The Boxoo extension for Chrome is free. It puts the audit where you already work: a Boxoo score in the top bar, chips beside the ad groups, keywords, and ads that have a case, and a chat with Claude that already knows your account. Ask “why did my cost per conversion go up?” on the page you are looking at.
How do I know if my Google Ads conversion tracking is broken?
Look for four signs: conversions that suddenly drop to zero while clicks continue, primary actions that have not recorded in weeks, conversions that appear only in the “All conversions” column, and a cost per conversion that looks too good. Boxoo’s free audit checks each of these from your account’s conversion settings and daily data.
What is the difference between primary and secondary conversion actions?
Primary actions feed the Conversions column and smart bidding. Secondary actions are only reported. In one audit, 21 of 22 real bookings were landing in secondary actions, so bidding was steering on a single conversion a month.
Should a lead action count “one” or “every”?
Usually one. If a person calls twice or taps WhatsApp twice after one click, “every” counts two leads and inflates the numbers bidding learns from. Purchases are the usual exception, where every sale counts.
Why does every conversion show a value of 1?
Because the action uses a default placeholder value. It is harmless with cost-per-conversion bidding, but any target ROAS or return figure becomes meaningless. Claude flags it whenever a return-based target is in play or being recommended.
Are map directions and call taps real conversions?
They are signals, not always leads. In one audit all 732 conversions in a month were directions or call-button taps while the lead form recorded none, so the campaign was optimising toward taps. Keep them as secondary unless they reliably become customers.
Does Boxoo fix conversion tracking for me?
Partly. Changes inside Google Ads, such as switching counting from every to one or changing the conversion window, can be applied with one click and an undo. Website tags and tag manager setup are outside Google Ads, so the case gives you exact steps instead.
Is the conversion tracking audit free?
Yes. It is part of the free Google Ads audit, with no card. The free Chrome extension shows the same cases inside Google Ads.